Erik's Rant
 

November 9, 2006

Professional Sports

I like watching sports for a number of reasons: the poetry in motion of a well-tuned and well-trained athlete is a concrete example off the Good, the True and the Beautiful; the drama of the contest between the cities is a positive and healthy manifestation of human competition; complimentarily, the social cohesion formed around a team is a postitive and healthy manifestation of the tribe instinct; the statistical patterning in a sport like baseball is an interesting manifestation of the musical arts; and there is not a sport out there that does not stand as an open invitation to drink beer.

These are all good things, although each one of these aspects is periodically assaulted by various nefarious forces: the healthy manifestation of competition and tribalism becomes a bestial parody in the hands of some Raiders' fans; the invitation to drink beer is thwarted at the hands of neo-Puritans on campuses who ban its sale in the stadia; etc.

The biggest destroyer of the Good, the True and the Beautiful in sports, however, are the team owners.

Here in the Bay Area (as well as in Sacramento), the team ownership of the A's, the Raiders, the FairyNiners, and the Kings, are currently or have recently played games with their host cities to try to wrest public financing of arenas at little cost to the teams' organizations themselves.

I say, if you want socialized sports, fine. I can get behind that completely. Let the cities own their own teams, or make the teams be publicly traded among bonafide residents of the cities' metro areas. It is for this reason that I remain a Packers' fan. The team doesn't go threatening to move to Las Vegas every four years.

Barring some sort of major overhaul to the nature of professional sports, my second choice would be for all of the Bay Area's teams, excluding the Giants, to leave. Go Away. Move to Timbuktu. I don't care. In terms of economic benefit, professional sports are a wash at best. When the strains they put on the communities are really measured (traffic, police, etc.), my guess is that most (not all) teams are a complete drain on their host cities.

Now, I also include this desire for the teams to vanish to extend to major college sports. Last Saturday we were in Berkeley, and it made me appreciate going to a school without football. We had swimming, tennis, even basketball (I think, although I never went to a game), lacrosse, and all of those other minor sports, which is great. In fact, I would probably pare it down even further in scope.

Today we read in the paper that the FairyNiners are going to move away. Good riddance. Obviously, this is a best case scenario for me, as I despise that team. I would probably be a little (not much, though), less jubilant if it were the A's, a team I like. But for the FairyNiners to move to Santa Clara (even better would be San Jose, Los Angeles' little colony in the North) is like a dream come true. Now I can loathe them with a completely clear conscience, not feeling the least bit like I am betraying the Great City of St. Francis.

The FairyNiners are moving to Perugia, as it were, and the Bay Area can rejoice that we are rid of their lame-ass, losing, Mormon-promoting ways!

Posted by erik at November 9, 2006 9:09 AM
Comments

Meredith, I thought the same exact thing when Erik posted that it would be near Great America. Thousands of people, Forty-Niner fans even, descending upon the defensless parking lot of Our Lady of Peace and using it for their own wretched purposes.

Anyway, I agree with you, Erik, about San Jose...about the only thing I will miss about this area when I leave it is the aforementioned Our Lady of Peace parish. San Jose has its myths, though...they just pretend myths. A professor here at Santa Clara University said "This is the most creative place in the world today. Some day they'll write histories of this valley like they do about the Renaissance in Florence." Well, I say if they do they are extraordinarilly misguided.

Often, as I return to San Jose from the Central Valley (my girlfriend lives in Fresno and I often go to visit her...Fresno of course has its own problems, but I much prefer it to San Jose) I feel an absolutely oppressive sense of "I'm in San Jose again." I really dislike San Jose. However, Los Angeles, in my mind, is worse than anything. I cannot imagine living there. Every time I'm there I notice that wherever I am I am about an hour from where I should be, even if where I should be is only a mile away or so. I really, really dislike Los Angeles.

Posted by: Daniel at November 13, 2006 1:15 AM

Great America? No! This cannot be! My parish is practically next door to it. If the niners move there, all sorts of obnoxious people will be trying to clog up our parking lot.

Oh well. More money for the enterprising little Filipino kids who are trying to go to the Holy Land or WYD or what have you.

Posted by: Meredith at November 11, 2006 12:12 PM

San Jose and Los Angeles share similar suburban sprawl, ticky tacky tract housing, the suplantation of a small, vibrant rural community with a history-less, formless, memory-less, and most importantly, myth-less void. The dot-com boom was their attempt at forging a compelling mythology, and it failed.

Of course there are mythologies that have taken root in Los Angeles, and there is far more culture, so in many ways Los Angeles is more interesting than San Jose. No, in practically every way Los Angeles is more interesting than San Jose.

Frankly, the best thing that could happen to San Jose would be to just close it up and tear it down. Let the one hundred twenty feet of the best topsoil in the world recover, and let the best stone fruit orchards in the world come back.

Perhaps the Niners are just playing footsie, but they apparently have a spot picked near Great America.

Posted by: Erik Keilholtz at November 10, 2006 8:36 AM

Why is San Jose "Los Angeles' little colony in the north"? Believe me, I don't like San Jose, but I've never noticed it to have much to do with Los Angeles.

BTW, are the Forty Niners really moving to Santa Clara? How? Where will they fit?

Posted by: Daniel at November 9, 2006 6:43 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?