December 14, 2003
On the Ugly German Composer
Maybe in my musical autobiography, I gave the impression that I detest everything Johannes Brahms ever wrote. This is not the case. I tend to like his large ensemble music. It is his chamber works that drive me to fits of rage, especially his piano music. I have no beef with the orchestral or choral works (in fact, singing the Neues Liebeslieder Walzer was one of the great musical joys of my life).
A similar situtation is found in Ravel, who could orchestrate like none other, but wrote the noodliest piano pieces known to man. I never could find anything to like in his piano music, even when I played the piano. It just seemed that one was wasting time playing Ravel, when one could be playing Debussy.
Posted by erik at December 14, 2003 5:23 PM | TrackBackErik-I'm intrigued by your comment about Ravel's orchestrating prowess. A musician friend of mine maintains that Ravel's compositions were all orchestrated by someone else, and that Ravel had no ability in this area. I've always understood the opposite to be true, as you write here. How do I convince my friend otherwise? John
Posted by: John Salmon at December 16, 2003 10:49 PM