Erik's Rant
 

August 8, 2003

Should I? Shouldn't I?

I am not asking myself this question, but it seems that everyone else in the State of California is (and I think they are all opting for the former). I cannot be Governor because I cannot promise to uphold the laws of this State. You see, there was a silly bit of legislation on the ballot that made eating horsemeat a felony. Not only eating horse, but selling a horse out of state, if you knew that the horse was going to be used for human consumption. I would not enforce such idiotic laws.

In fact it was with great joy that I barbecued horse steaks for the family in Italy last year. My Mom said, "great, this is the pony that I always wanted as a child." It went well with pici with mushrooms.

It is not that I dislike horses. I love the sight of a horse running, standing, walking, rearing, etc. They are magnificent animals, but they are that: simply animals. I love bull bovines as well, especially when they are in the ring participating in the art of the bullfights. I also love them in boef gardienne de la comargue. None of this precludes my love of the sight of a wild bovine grazing on the hillside, tossing its horns through the air, roaring in May, charging other bulls for supremacy. It is all a matter of order and proportion. The proper place for animals in an animal-human relationship is to serve and be used by humans for food, clothing, shelter, art, entertainment, transportation, etc.

We must thoroughly repudiate any and all claims to "animal rights." One time I encountered a fellow who said, "oh, I definitely think that animals should have more rights." How do you respond to such a defective view of natural rights? He views rights as a function of a social contract and then wants to extend that to creatures incapable of entering into a contract. At the same time he believes abortion to be a good.

If only this fellow were a freak, a moron, someone who slipped through the cracks of our education sysytem. Instead his understanding is the understanding most people have in our society about the nature of government. They talk about inalienable rights without understanding what that means. They wish to extend "rights" at the same time they wish to trample natural rights.

And that is what most of the candidates for governor are going to be offering. Ugggh.

Posted by erik at August 8, 2003 3:06 PM | TrackBack
Comments

Tom McClintock is pro-life. Erik Keilholtz is a horse murderer.

Posted by: Jeff Culbreath at August 12, 2003 5:49 PM

Peter Singer is the best example of the cognitive dissonance of PETA style animal worship. The guy promotes infanticide, yet wants to free lab animals. And he is held up as a 'prominent ethicist'.
I am a carnivore, but I am not fond of cheval nor, to be honest, lapin. But I defend your (or anyone's) right to eat what you choose.

Posted by: alicia the midwife at August 12, 2003 5:49 PM

Dear Erik,

I share neither your opinions on animals, nor your enthusiasms; however, I certainly share your opinion of the candidates. The thought of six years with that accent pounding in my head every time I had to see the governor would be enough to make me think very carefully.

You probably should run. I'd be most interested to see how much of California would vote for the incarnation of anti-PETA (certainly an admirable avatar, if I could ever think of one--I'm annoyed by people who value animal life over the life of human children--[much of the animal rights movement--save the antelope by curtailing population through the anti-sacrament of abortion]) One final point on your candidacy--don't you think California needs at least one pro-life candidate?

shalom,

Steven

Posted by: Steven Riddle at August 12, 2003 5:49 PM

Jeff,

Ann is working on it. You will note that almost all the links are zapped for now. They will be back one way or another.

Computers are a strange business indeed.

Posted by: Erik Keilholtz at August 12, 2003 3:36 PM

OK, this is better. Now I really hate to be a Johnny-one-note, but where is my .... oh nevermind.

Posted by: Jeff Culbreath at August 12, 2003 3:31 PM

I think there were some comments here that got nuked over the weekend. I am not sure what happened, all I know is that it is back up, thanks to Ann, and all is well!

If you want me to find your comments and post them administratively, I can do that!

Posted by: Erik Keilholtz at August 12, 2003 1:41 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?